Used vs. leased cars…….Okay, let’s just say it: cars are expensive. I mean, like “I should just buy a horse and name him Jeff” expensive. But since my HOA is weirdly anti-horse (seriously, there’s a whole section in the bylaws), I had to pick between used vs. leased cars when I finally gave up on my dying Toyota that made weird gurgling noises every time I hit the brakes.
And wow, did I go down a rabbit hole trying to figure out what actually saves more money—and what just feels like a good deal until you’re crying over your 3-year lease terms at 2AM with a bag of Cool Ranch Doritos.
So here’s what I learned—messy, honest, unfiltered—and what I wish someone had told me before I signed anything.
The Time I Almost Leased a BMW (Big Mistake. Huge.)
Let me set the scene.
I walk into this luxury dealership with zero plans of leasing anything. I was just looking. Just browsing. And then this guy with perfect teeth and a polo shirt that costs more than my entire wardrobe shows me this BMW 3 Series. Sparkling. Leather. That new car smell that hits harder than nostalgia.
I ask what the catch is.
“Oh, just $499 a month with $3,000 down.”
And I was like, “I’ve paid more for random Amazon junk over the years.”
But then I did the math—eventually. That’s $499 x 36 months. Add the $3K. Toss in maintenance I’m still responsible for. And I have to give it back at the end?
Pass.
(Also, the dealer kept calling me “brother,” which was unsettling.)
So… What’s the Real Deal with Leasing?
If you’re the type who gets bored easily (with cars, not, like, relationships—I’m not here to judge), leasing might feel like your jam. You get a new car every few years. Warranty usually covers stuff. And yes, your neighbors might think you’re more successful than you actually are.
But here’s the rub:
- You’re basically renting a car.
- You don’t own squat at the end.
- You have mileage caps. (Don’t even think about road tripping cross-country unless you love overage fees.)
- If you scratch the bumper? You pay. Lose a key fob? You pay. Breathe too hard in it? You probably pay.
Still, the monthly payments are lower, and it’s shiny and new.
So yeah. Leasing is kinda like dating a model who insists on being driven to brunch every Sunday—fun, expensive, and not long-term material.
Meanwhile, Back in Used Car Land…
Used cars are like thrift store finds. Sometimes you find a gem. Sometimes you get a haunted toaster.
When I bought my used Honda Accord, it had 54,000 miles, a minor dent on the passenger side, and a backstory that sounded like it belonged in a Hallmark movie. (Previous owner: retired librarian who only drove it to Trader Joe’s and church.)
I paid $14K. That was it. No monthly payments, no long-term contract. Just me and my slightly dented baby, driving into the sunset.
Used cars:
- Are cheaper upfront
- Don’t come with that brand-new-car-depreciation (you lose like 20% of a new car’s value just driving off the lot—madness)
- Give you ownership and freedom
- Let you sell later, keep longer, and not panic about every scratch
BUT!
- They may need more maintenance (mine developed a weird rattle I’ve named “Cheryl”)
- You gotta be careful about shady history
- Warranty? Usually lol nope
So it’s a trade-off. You save long term but you gotta be ready for some bumps.
So… Which Saves You More?
Let’s break it down, very not scientifically.
Leasing:
- Lower monthly payment: ✅
- Always under warranty: ✅
- Always new and flashy: ✅
- Ongoing payments forever: ❌
- Fees and mileage limits: ❌
- No ownership equity: ❌
Used Cars:
- Bigger upfront cost (unless you finance): ❌
- Higher maintenance potential: ❌
- You own it: ✅
- No limits: ✅
- You can sell it later: ✅
If you care about long-term savings, used wins.
If you care about low stress now, leasing’s easier.
But honestly? If you’re trying to build wealth, reduce debt, or not freak out every time your lease is up—go used.
Unless you’re rich. In which case, why are you reading this? Go buy a Tesla and wave from your sunroof.
The One Thing Nobody Told Me…
Car insurance. Yeah.
Leased cars usually cost more to insure. Because the car is worth more. Because you have to follow all these requirements. Because life isn’t fair.
My used Honda? I pay like $80/month. My friend’s leased Kia EV6? Nearly double. For a Kia!
Also, you can mod a used car. You wanna slap anime decals on the hood or glue a spoiler on the back? Go nuts. You try that on a leased vehicle and the dealership will end you.
Bottom Line about used vs. leased cars
Buying used is like adopting a scruffy rescue dog. A little unpredictable. Might need some TLC. But it’s yours, and it loves you back.
Leasing is like borrowing your rich cousin’s designer handbag. Gorgeous, yes. But don’t spill anything on it.
So yeah—used saves more. In dollars, in flexibility, in sanity. But leasing feels easier. Just be real with yourself about what matters most. (Hint: it’s probably not impressing strangers in the parking lot.)
Now, I’m off to see if Cheryl the Honda is still making that noise when I turn left. Wish me luck.
Suggested Outbound Links:
